• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Before Header

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

This Electric Home

Keeping It Clean, Quiet, and Easy

  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Home Maintenance
    • Air Compressors
    • Carpet Cleaners
    • Pressure Washers
      • Greenworks
      • Homdox
      • Ryobi
      • Stanley
      • Sun Joe
    • Snow Blowers
      • Electric
      • Single Stage
      • Two-Stage
      • Ariens
        • Ariens Compact 24
        • Ariens Deluxe 24
        • Ariens Deluxe 28″
      • Honda
      • Husqvarna
        • Husqvarna ST224P
      • Troy-Bilt
        • Troy-Bilt Squall 2100
    • Water Purification
      • Reverse Osmosis Systems
      • Water Softeners
      • Whole-House Water Filters
        • Aquasana
      • Under-Sink Water Filters
  • Home Climate
    • Air Purifier For Smoke
    • Electric Fireplace
      • Dimplex
      • Duraflame
      • Corner
      • Free Standing
      • Infrared
      • Linear
      • TV Stands
      • Wall Mount
    • Dehumidifiers
    • Dehumidifiers for Basements
    • Garage Heaters
      • Fahrenheat
      • King Electric
      • ProFusion
    • Tower Fans
    • Window Air Conditioners
  • Home Necessities
    • Food and Drinks
      • Cold Brew Coffee Makers
      • Electric Tea Kettles
      • Hot Plates
      • Electric Skillets
      • Electric Grills
      • Charcoal Smokers
      • Electric Smokers
      • Pellet Smokers
      • Propane Smokers
      • Pellet Stoves
      • Wood Stoves
    • Garage Door Openers
      • Quiet
      • WiFi
      • Chamberlain
        • Chamberlain B550
        • Chamberlain B970
        • Chamberlain WD832KEV
      • LiftMaster
        • LiftMaster 8355
        • Liftmaster 8500
        • Liftmaster 8550W
      • Ryobi
  • Leisure
    • Electric Skateboards
    • Home Relaxation
      • Bathroom Vanities
      • Infrared Sauna
      • Massage Chairs
      • Oil Diffusers
      • Sleeping Needs
        • Futons
          • For Everyday Sleeping
        • Mattress Toppers
    • Paitball Guns
  • Pets
    • Air Purifier For Pets
    • Aquarium Heaters
    • Automatic Dog Feeder
    • Carpet Cleaners for Pets
    • Dog Clippers
    • Electric Dog Fence
      • Extreme
      • GPS
      • Halo
      • PetSafe
      • Sit Boo-Boo
      • SportDOG
      • SpotOn vs. Halo
      • SpotOn
      • WIEZ
    • Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes
  • Contact
  • Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Home Maintenance
    • Air Compressors
    • Carpet Cleaners
    • Pressure Washers
      • Greenworks
      • Homdox
      • Ryobi
      • Stanley
      • Sun Joe
    • Snow Blowers
      • Electric
      • Single Stage
      • Two-Stage
      • Ariens
        • Ariens Compact 24
        • Ariens Deluxe 24
        • Ariens Deluxe 28″
      • Honda
      • Husqvarna
        • Husqvarna ST224P
      • Troy-Bilt
        • Troy-Bilt Squall 2100
    • Water Purification
      • Reverse Osmosis Systems
      • Water Softeners
      • Whole-House Water Filters
        • Aquasana
      • Under-Sink Water Filters
  • Home Climate
    • Air Purifier For Smoke
    • Electric Fireplace
      • Dimplex
      • Duraflame
      • Corner
      • Free Standing
      • Infrared
      • Linear
      • TV Stands
      • Wall Mount
    • Dehumidifiers
    • Dehumidifiers for Basements
    • Garage Heaters
      • Fahrenheat
      • King Electric
      • ProFusion
    • Tower Fans
    • Window Air Conditioners
  • Home Necessities
    • Food and Drinks
      • Cold Brew Coffee Makers
      • Electric Tea Kettles
      • Hot Plates
      • Electric Skillets
      • Electric Grills
      • Charcoal Smokers
      • Electric Smokers
      • Pellet Smokers
      • Propane Smokers
      • Pellet Stoves
      • Wood Stoves
    • Garage Door Openers
      • Quiet
      • WiFi
      • Chamberlain
        • Chamberlain B550
        • Chamberlain B970
        • Chamberlain WD832KEV
      • LiftMaster
        • LiftMaster 8355
        • Liftmaster 8500
        • Liftmaster 8550W
      • Ryobi
  • Leisure
    • Electric Skateboards
    • Home Relaxation
      • Bathroom Vanities
      • Infrared Sauna
      • Massage Chairs
      • Oil Diffusers
      • Sleeping Needs
        • Futons
          • For Everyday Sleeping
        • Mattress Toppers
    • Paitball Guns
  • Pets
    • Air Purifier For Pets
    • Aquarium Heaters
    • Automatic Dog Feeder
    • Carpet Cleaners for Pets
    • Dog Clippers
    • Electric Dog Fence
      • Extreme
      • GPS
      • Halo
      • PetSafe
      • Sit Boo-Boo
      • SportDOG
      • SpotOn vs. Halo
      • SpotOn
      • WIEZ
    • Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes
This article may contain affiliate links, read our disclosure for details.

SpotOn Virtual Fence vs. Halo Collar Comparison

If you are a dog owner, you probably want optimal peace of mind. The good news is that a smart dog collar system can give you the peace of mind that you have always wanted.

Halo Collar is recognized as a top dog collar containment solution. The primary purpose of the product is to ensure that pups stay safely contained in a virtual fence, allowing your dog to enjoy a life unleashed.

SpotOn Virtual Fence is also praised for being a truly incredible dog containment solution. The product is specifically designed to provide next-generation dog containment, empowering your pup to live its best life.

SpotOn Virtual Fence

SpotOn Virtual Fence.
Check Latest Price →
  • SpotOn is a great dog collar containment solution for obedient and well-tempered dogs
  • Perfect for pups with necks between 10” and 26”
  • Uses True Location™ technology for the most reliable GPS dog fence

There are many benefits to choosing the SpotOn GPS Fence. The dog collar can work on almost any property that’s at least ½ acre. SpotOn allows you to store up to 10 custom GPS fences. You can use the dog collar for roughly 18 hours without needing to charge it.

Halo Collar

Halo Collar.
Check Latest Price →
  • The Halo Collar is an excellent dog collar containment solution for more disobedient pups
  • The collar works best on small, medium, and large dogs with necks between 11” and 30.5”
  • Available for pup ages 5 months plus

The Halo Collar is a top dog containment solution for many reasons. For starters, the product comes with extensive dog training to ensure that pups learn boundaries, rules, and limitations. Many dog owners love that this dog collar features activity tracking, enabling them to track their pups’ number of daily walks and time spent resting.


If you are a dog owner, you probably want optimal peace of mind. The good news is that a smart dog collar system can give you the peace of mind that you have always wanted.

Features

Instantly Create Wireless Fences

Set up a wireless fence in limitless locations even if you don’t have a WiFi connection. The customer perimeters can be of virtually any size or shape. You will truly enjoy being able to create fences on the go with simply a tap of the finger. Smart collars can truly be used anytime, anywhere.

Halo Collar

Pros
  • No digging needed to set up to 20 fences virtually anywhere in the world
  • Features GPS and GNSS systems
Cons
  • May be not as effective in really remote areas with no cellular coverage

SpotOn Virtual Fence

Pros
  • Create up to 10 custom perimeters with up to 1,500 fence posts in each fence
  • Multiple satellite constellations that connect to 25-30 satellites at once
Cons
  • Cell coverage should be strong, otherwise it won’t work as efficiently

Automatic Tracking

As a responsible dog owner, your primary goal is to keep your pup safe and sound. Due to GPS and real-time location tracking, you will know where your pup is at all times.

The automatic tracking via fast, reliable cellular technology, Wi-FI, and GPS lets you know exactly what your pup is up to every second of the day.

Halo Collar

Pros
  • Also comes with prevention tracking to prevent emergencies before they actually occur
  • Features in-app and push notifications about your pup’s whereabouts
Cons
  • GPS may not calibrate correctly if there are many trees nearby

SpotOn Virtual Fence

Pros
  • Tapping “refresh” allows you to see exactly where your pup is located
  • Real-time tracking updates every 6 seconds and positions dog to within 10 feet of its actual location
Cons
  • Tracking feature may not work with spotty cell coverage

Incredible Training

Set your pup up for optimal success by following a powerful training program. The main goal of this excellent training program is to ensure that your pup has an extremely positive experience with the new dog collar. During the training program, your pup will learn some key rules, limitations, and boundaries. Once the training is successfully completed, your pup will know how to live without a leash.

Halo Collar

Pros
  • Led by celebrity dog trainer Cesar Millan
  • You’ll have access to exclusive monthly training and comprehensive behavioral training with the gold plan.
Cons
  • The training will take 21 days to complete

SpotOn Virtual Fence

Pros
  • A simple DIY training program that has your dog ready to go in a couple of weeks
  • Offers an exclusive selection of highly qualified dog trainers to work with you personally
Cons
  • The training may not work for anxious or disobedient pups

Alert And Warning Tones

Smart collars will keep your pup safely contained inside the virtual fence with alert and warning tones. If your dog ignores the alerts and warning tones, a static correction will be issued.

Halo Collar

Pros
  • Offers an extensive array of sounds and vibration patterns
  • Pups will receive a customized warning
Cons
  • Pups may still exit the virtual fence

SpotOn Virtual Fence

Pros
  • There is a lot of room for dogs to roam without them hearing the alerts and warning tones
  • If your pup exits the containment, an escape notification will be sent to your phone if the tracking is turned on
Cons
  • Dogs may still leave the containment

All Terrain Types

Works on virtually any terrain type, so your dog can cross driveways, rivers, streams, boulders, wooded areas, and much more.

Halo Collar

Pros
  • Boasts an IP-67 water rating, which is perfect if your pup likes to doggy paddle in swamps and lakes
  • Regardless of the location, the fences are completely automated via GPS, and the collar’s internal components
Cons
  • May not work in heavily wooded areas

SpotOn Virtual Fence

Pros
  • Truly unlimited property size
  • Offers a forest mode for really dense tree areas
Cons
  • Minimum property size is ½ an acre

Incredible Battery Life

Smart collars have a fantastic battery life, offering up to an entire day of containment in many cases. The battery life is dependent upon many factors such as the pup’s level of activity, the amount of time a dog spends indoors, and the quality of cellular connection.

You’ll absolutely love that the battery is fully rechargeable.

Halo Collar

Pros
  • The battery will last 24 hours
Cons
  • The battery needs to be removed every night to avoid irritation

SpotOn Virtual Fence

Pros
  • The battery will last for an entire day
  • Get real-time alerts when the battery is low
Cons
  • The battery will only last about eight hours with the tracking mode turned on

What to Choose?

Halo Collar.
Check Latest Price →

The Halo Collar is ideal for pups that may need extra guidance from an experienced dog trainer. Just think of the Halo Collar as the perfect dog containment solution for dogs that are a little stubborn and disobedient. Of course, the Halo Collar will work for virtually any pup

SpotOn Virtual Fence.
Check Latest Price →

The SpotOn Virtual Fence is an excellent dog containment solution that will work for a wide variety of pups, but it’s geared toward more obedient pups due to a lack of extensive training. If pups are generally well-mannered and obedient, they will be trained in just a few sessions.

About Tom Collins

Hey, I’m Tom Collins!

General contractor extraordinaire, I have a flair for testing out and reviewing some of the best home products money can buy. My team’s reviews have helped thousands of folks across the globe and my career in home improvement has given me a lot of insight into what makes a good, lasting product, and what is just crap.

Poke around, explore, and welcome to This Electric Home!

  • Contact
  • Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2023 This Electric Home · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme